Grateful Doe was the nickname given to a formally unidentified car accident victim. The victim was identified as Jason Callahan in 2015, 20 years after his death.
Jason Patrick Callahan was born in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina on April 18, 1976. He was a huge fan of the American rock band The Grateful Dead. At the time of his death, the 19 year old left his home to go follow The Grateful Dead on tour on June 1, 1995. This was the last time his mother remembers seeing him.
On June 26, 1995, Jason was still following the Grateful Dead. He got a ride from another Grateful Dead fan, 21 year old Michael Hager. At about 1:30 P.M., the car that the two young men were riding in crashed into a pair of trees in Emporia, Virginia. It was determined that Michael had possibly fallen asleep behind the wheel since neither of them had drugs or alcohol in their systems at the time of their deaths. Neither of them were wearing their seatbelts, which more than likely contributed to both their deaths. Jason died of blunt force trauma caused by the accident.
With Jason’s body, several items were found. This included two scalped Grateful Dead tickets, which were dated for June 24 and June 25, 1995, a dollar in quarters, and a yellow Bic lighter. A note was also found with Jason, which read “Jason, Sorry we had to go, see ya around, call me #914-XXXX Caroline T. & Caroline O. Bye!!!!”. The phone number could not be traced back to the person who wrote the note and it is unknown who the “Carolines” are.
At the time of his death, Jason was wearing a red, tie-dyed Grateful Dead t-shirt, Levi’s jeans, white socks, and black Fila running shoes. He was estimated to be between 15 and 21 years old. He had brown eyes and long curly brown/dark blonde hair that had been dyed a reddish color. Jason also had a star tattoo on his upper left arm and another on his right arm that was slightly faded. He was also wearing a beaded necklace and his left ear was pierced, but there was no jewelry in it. Examiners noted the Jason also had a scar on his back, was Caucasian, and had no dental work but his teeth were well cared for.
After the deaths, Michael Hager was immediately identified, but authorities could not identify Jason. They tried to identify him through fingerprints, but that was unsuccessful. Michael Hager’s family was interviewed, but they told authorities that they had no idea who the other young man might be.
Facial reconstructions were made for Jason. Due to the severe lacerations on Jason’s face caused by the accident, his autopsy photos could not be released to the public for his identification. Another facial reconstruction was made in 2012 by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, and at least 221 missing people were ruled out as the victim. Jason remained unidentified and was eventually given the nickname “Grateful Doe”.
In January 2015 in Queensland, Australia, a Reddit user by the name of Leila Betts came across the case of the Grateful Doe while researching unsolved mysteries. Leila started getting more information about the case and later posted an article to Imager with information about it, such as his cause of death, what he was wearing, the items found on him, as well as the facial reconstructions of Jason. Leila posted this in hopes that someone would recognize Jason, which worked!
Leila got a message on Reddit from a guy named Steve regarding the Grateful Doe case. Steve recognized the facial reconstruction and said it looked like one of his old roommates from Illinois whose name was Jason. He described Jason as a young, free, hippie surfer. Steve said that at the time of his death, Jason was working at a local McDonald’s and enjoyed discussing topics like Atheism and hallucinogens, and he was a huge “Dead Head” (name given to Grateful Dead fans), much like the unidentified Grateful Doe. Steve said he hadn’t seen Jason since 1995 and showed photographs of Jason to Leila, which obviously had a striking resemblance to the Grateful Doe.
Jason’s case began to grow in the mainstream media not long after this. The photos that Steve shared with Leila comparing Jason to the Grateful Doe went viral and was eventually seen on Facebook by a woman named Margaretta Evans. She stated that the young man in the photos was her son, Jason Callahan. In early 2015, a DNA test was conducted to see if Jason really was the Grateful Doe, and it was a match. The spokesperson for the Myrtle Beach police, Lt. Joey Crosby, said that Jason’s mother failed to report him missing due to the nomadic nature of the Grateful Dead fans; “she attempted to report it when he went missing but didn’t know which jurisdiction to report it to.” Jason’s family all assumed that he had just went off to go live on his own elsewhere after not hearing from him.
Although this case is finally closed and the Grateful Doe is now identified, it still makes me sad how everything played out. Jason went so many years without being identified, something that I’m sure could’ve easily happened at the time had he been correctly reported missing. It’s great that we now have social media to bring attention to cold cases like this, but this case in particular just gives me a melancholy feeling. In the end, Jason Callahan is now identified and that is all that matters.
Resources-
TRUE CRIME REPORT 